Because You Never Asked
Returning to the Fringe from Montréal acclaimed company, We All Fall Down Interdisciplinary Creations, presents Because You Never Asked in the intimate surroundings of Summerhall’s Main Hall.
About Because You Never Asked
We All Fall Down are returning to Edinburgh’s Festival Fringe after a hugely successful Fringe debut in 2023 with PAPILLON. Because You Never Asked is part of Québec’s annual Edinburgh Festivals showcase, Québec @EdFests, which has brought some of the best and most popular shows at Edinburgh Festival Fringe.
Because You Never Asked is an interdisciplinary piece blending dance, music and storytelling to chronicle a poignant moment of intergenerational exchange. At its core is a series of conversations between creator Roger White and his grandmother, Marianna Clark (née Goldmann), about a hidden life lived under the Nazi regime.
The performance blends a haunting soundscape, featuring recorded conversations, with evocative choreography that serves to embody memory.
The project is rooted in the remarkable true story of Marianna Clark (née Goldmann), Roger White’s grandmother, who was born in Germany in 1922 and grew up near Hamburg in a Jewish-Christian family. In 1939, after the passage of the Nuremberg Laws and the revocation of their citizenship, Marianna’s family fled Nazi Germany for Edinburgh.
For years, these experiences remained unspoken, until recent conversations between Marianna and her grandson opened a window onto her memories. When Roger asked her why she had never shared these stories before, her answer was simple: “Because you never asked.”
Blending excerpts from Marianna’s diaries, written while studying in Edinburgh during her late teens and early twenties, with recordings of Roger’s conversations with Marianna in her 90s, the piece unfolds across two interwoven timelines. Past and present collide to explore how our personal histories are shaped, re-shaped and sometimes rewritten over time.
Edinburgh plays a central role in this deeply personal story. During her time in the city, Marianna was a student at the Polish School of Medicine at The University of Edinburgh, a unique wartime initiative created to meet the needs of students and doctors in the Polish armed forces between 1941-1949. She was among the first five women ever admitted to the school, which marked a groundbreaking moment in both medical and women’s education during the war.
Now, decades later, Marianna’s story returns to Edinburgh – brought to life at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, just streets away from where she once lived and studied.
This interdisciplinary work is a cautionary tale that highlights the perils of anti-immigrant narratives, told through stories that shift between humour and darkness while documenting the slow march toward authoritarianism. It is a heartwarming reminder to honour the wisdom of those who came before us, and to hold on to the memory of those we cherish most.
Founded in 2019, We All Fall Down (WAFD) is a non-profit organisation that supports and promotes creation, research, presentation and innovation in dance, music and theatre through interdisciplinary artistic propositions. WAFD formalises the 20-year collaboration between choreographer Helen Simard and composer Roger White.
Where possible we will update our listings to notify of cancelled, postponed and rescheduled events, however we STRONGLY ADVISE that you check with the venue/organiser in the first instance for updates.
All information (whether in text or photographs) is supplied in good faith but should not be relied upon as being a statement of representation or fact.GOT AN EVENT TO SHARE? It's free to post your events on What's On Edinburgh, click here to find out more!
Want to be the first to hear about what's happening in Edinburgh? Follow us on Facebook and join the What's On Scotland Group!Sponsored Links
Other Events at Summerhall or Edinburgh Festival Fringe
Almost Impossible 2.0: Martin Brock
Martin Brock is back at the Fringe with an electrifying, one-of-a-kind spectacle of slick, mind-bending magic, laugh-out-loud comedy, cutting-edge video production and astonishing illusions!
READ MORE
TBC Improv UK’s Monthly Open Improv Jam
TBC invites you to a monthly improv drop-in jam. It's a fun inclusive event where absolutely all are welcome, no improv experience required.
READ MORE
Vibrant Viki’s Messy Art Club
Vibrant Viki’s Messy Art Club is a lively, hands-on creative experience designed especially for children under five who love to explore, play, and get wonderfully messy.
READ MORE
TBC Improv UK: Intro to Improv Course (101)
TBC Improv's 'Into to Improv Course' is your invitation to explore the fundamentals of improvisation in a supportive, playful environment on this 8 week course — no experience needed.
READ MOREEdinburgh Ceilidh Club at Summerhall
Come and experience Scottish dance the way its meant to be every Tuesday at the Edinburgh Ceilidh Club in Summerhall!
READ MORE
Acrylic Inks Art Workshop
Dive into the magic of acrylic inks to create vibrant, nature-inspired art using explosive wet-on-wet techniques and colorful layering in this experimental workshop at Summerhall on 22nd January!
READ MORE
TBC & Friends: A night of improvised comedy
Get ready for a high-octane night of improv comedy as TBC Improv UK takes the Summerhall stage for an unforgettable evening of spontaneous brilliance!
READ MORE
Improv Workshop Intensives: Viewpoints, Music, Duoprov
Unlock tools for physical storytelling, musicality, and duo-based improv that deepen trust, emotion, and creative freedom in this immersive weekend intensive at Summerhall.
READ MORE
CATALYST: Art as Activism - All Day, Waiting For Another Sun to Rise
Within this show at Summerhall, Molly Wickett reimagines a post-apocalyptic landscape through a queer and disabled lens.
READ MORE
CATALYST: Art as Activism - Any Body Home
Any Body Home features works developed during the Hugo Burge Foundation x Summerhall residency Art as Activism (2024), along with other pieces exploring related themes.
READ MORE
CATALYST: Art as Activism - A Heart in Exile
A Heart in Exile brings together three bodies of work that trace the inner landscape of migration; its fractures, its expansions, and its quiet, unresolvable tensions.
READ MORE
CATALYST: Art as Activism - Net Worthy
Net Worthy explores how capitalism drives biodiversity loss through its emphasis on extraction via industrial agriculture and aquaculture to produce perpetual profit.
READ MORE
Auntie Empire
Blending bouffon comedy, satire and audience interaction, Auntie Empire is a bloody, messy, hilarious and timely lampoon of the myths of nationhood. Catch it at Summerhall in February!
READ MORETBC & Friends: A night of improvised comedy
The TBC Improv UK troupe takes to the Summerhall stage on Friday 20th February, accompanied by a special guest performance!
READ MORE
Drawing Out of Darkness
Unleash your creativity in this workshop at Summerhall as you master the versatile art of charcoal, using Frank Auerbach's iconic techniques to build and deconstruct bold, expressive masterpieces!
READ MORE
TBC Improv Presents: Fresh Faces of Improv - Longform!
Get ready for a showcase of the newest improv comedy talent in Scotland with TBC Improv UK!
READ MORE
TBC Improv Presents: Fresh Faces of Improv - Shortform!
Get ready for a night of unscripted hilarity featuring some of the most exciting new voices in Edinburgh’s improv scene!
READ MORE
Ink Drawing Workshop
Come along to Summerhall and have fun at this lively ink drawing workshop where you'll experiment with fun tools and techniques to capture the beauty of nature and stunning Japanese gardens!
READ MORE
TBC Improv: Intro to Longform Improv Course (103)
This Intro to Longform is an 8-class course that builds on core improv skills and introduces the tools needed to create connected, meaningful shows.
READ MORE
TBC Improv: Cast & Conquer: Forming an Improv Group (Elective)
TBC Improv: Cast & Conquer is a 4-week intermediate course designed to help improvisers take the leap from classmate to castmate.
READ MORE
Guest Workshop: Solo-Prov & Being Obvious
Learn to be present, obvious, and boldly simple as David Elms guides you through grounded improv and the joyful art of solo-prov in this workshop at Summerhall.
READ MORE
TBC Improv: Intermediate Shortform Improv Course (202)
Intermediate Shortform is an 8-class course that sharpens your instincts, expands your game vocabulary, and teaches you how to play shortform with precision, creativity, and confidence.
READ MORE
Guest Masterclass: Shortform & Calvinball
Boost your short form skills and embrace rule-breaking creativity in Calvinball with Hayley Kellett. A weekend of joyful, fearless play.|
READ MORE
Forth on The Fringe
Forth on the Fringe is the annual one stop shop for all the essential acts you need to see at this year’s Edinburgh Festival. Catch it at Edinburgh Playhouse on 7th & 8th August!
READ MORE
Edinburgh Festival Fringe
The Edinburgh Fringe returns from 7th to 31st August 2026 with artists and performers taking to hundreds of stages all over the city to present shows for every taste.
READ MORESponsored Links
Similar events you might like...
Edinburgh Ceilidh Club at Assembly Roxy
Come and experience Scottish dance the way its meant to be every month at the Edinburgh Ceilidh Club at the Assembly Roxy!
READ MORE
Edinburgh Ceilidh Club at Summerhall
Come and experience Scottish dance the way its meant to be every Tuesday at the Edinburgh Ceilidh Club in Summerhall!
READ MORE
Burns Night Ceilidh
Get ready to dance the night away at this Burns Night Ceilidh in aid of Alzheimer's Research UK, where traditional Scottish food and lively reels will keep you moving all evening!
READ MORE
Museum Late: Big Burns Ceilidh
Enjoy a night like no other in the beautiful setting of the National Museum of Scotland at night as the fantastic Jacobites Ceilidh Band bring the Grand Gallery to life!
READ MORE
Edinburgh Open House Ceilidhs
Join Edinburgh Open House Ceilidhs with Live Band & Caller, held in the Royal British Legion Hall! Great informal fun night suitable for all ages (10yrs+).
READ MORE
Burns Night Supper
To celebrate Burns Night, Lost Shore has partnered with Fable Whisky for an evening of Scottish tradition, storytelling and flavour on Saturday 24th January!
READ MORE
Laldie Ceilidh with Da Hooley Band plus a Dose of Burns
Celebrate Burns Night with a full Laldie Ceilidh, featuring Da Hooley Ceilidh Band, with bonus Burns recitals at the Assembly Roxy on Saturday 24th January!
READ MORE
Burn’s Night Ceilidh
Join us for a lively Ceilidh Friday at The Three Sisters as Maggie’s Chamber transforms into a night of traditional music, energetic dancing, and great atmosphere.
READ MORE
Portobello Grand Ceilidh
Welcome to the Porty Town Hall Grand Fundraising Ceilidh! Join us for a fantastic night dancing to Bella McNab’s Ceilidh Band. Together we can laugh, dance and raise funds to support our local hall.
READ MOREFind other events in Edinburgh
Sponsored Links